Justice

The Social Justice Commission of the Anglican Church of Aotearoa & Polynesia

Select topics to browse

Close

Tax Cuts and Income Inequality

By / 28 May 2010

Budget 2010 has worsened income inequality in New Zealand. We have had a problem of a widening income gap for years mainly because of low wages for many and high income for a few. But this inequality is magnified if there are also tax reductions which favour those on high incomes.

There are many measures of inequality. One easy measure to use is the difference in take home pay. Of course this does not take account of Working for Families, or the effect of property taxes.


But as you can see from the Table, the gap in take home pay between workers on $30,000, $40,000 and so on and someone on $120,000 will widen considerably in October. The gap between someone on $30,000 and $120,000 grows by $72.89 and even the gap between someone on $60,000 and $120,000 grows by $53.85.

If we look at some other examples apart from those in the Table, someone on $15 an hour and compare them with someone on $50 an hour or $104,000 a year, the gap in take home pay now is $916.08. In October the gap will be $56.69 higher at $972.77. And the increase in the gap in take home pay between someone on $200,000 and $30,000 grows by $150 a week ($149.81).

The Government will argue that property taxes will even up this inequality to an extent. While it may be true that those who own investment properties are likely to be on high incomes, the reverse is not true. There are plenty of high income earners that will not be affected by new property taxes and those who are affected have the option to move their investments elsewhere. And in any case we are yet to see what effect these taxes have whereas we know the impact of GST will be a higher cost of living and some will face higher rents and early childhood education costs contributing to a steep rise in inflation.


In fact, if we include the impact of GST the income gap widens even further. This graph shows the difference between someone on the minimum wage and those on twice, three times, four times and ten times the minimum wage. It also takes account of the GST increase. Look at the huge difference in benefit from the tax package.

- Thanks to Peter Conway and Bill Rosenberg -

Facebook comments:

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

About us

This site is run by the Social Justice Commission of the Anglican Church.

We seek to nurture justice spirituality and imagination, and engage in advocacy in all areas of life, overcoming poverty and transforming violence.

We encourage people to think and live “justly”, and emphasise debate and action on local, national and global issues.

Although we are Anglican, our vision isn’t so much about being Anglican. It’s about living justly. Justice is about how you live your life, and being just where we are. Working together, we can all flourish.

×

Just Booklets Mailing List

Just Booklets produced by the Justice Commission appear as booklets  and study guides around a variety of important and engaging topics – food, gardening, peace, lignite, with many more to come. From now on, they will be coming directly to you.

Just Living Booklets are subscription-only publications, so if you or your church want copies, sign up! There is no charge. Simple as that.

You might like to consider becoming a contact person/distributor to help raise awareness of Just Booklets  in your church or organisation.If you have an idea for a booklet, or even the desire to write. We seek to draw upon the expertise of the whole church. If you’d like to share your story about some aspect of justice or injustice, or some story about your passions and/or your life, email or call Anthony.